Login  |  Register

Author Topic: Photon Grenades and 4th edition assault.  (Read 1240 times)

0 Members and 1 Guest are viewing this topic.

Offline Mystic511

  • Full Member
  • ***
  • Posts: 282
  • I *Love* EldarOnline! No, really, i do!
    • Personal Website
Photon Grenades and 4th edition assault.
« on: August 2, 2002, 05:21:30 AM »
Well, 4th edition assault rules say that if you shoot before you charge, then you lose your +1 attack bonus.

Photon grenades say any unit assault the unit with photons loses their +1 charge bonus.

Well, then, say a squad of 10 will usually get about 20 attacks in a charge.  Since the photon grenades would cancel 10 of those attacks, i think now in 4th edition, that ten man squad will elect to shoot before assaulting, which will still give them 20 attacks, since they know they'll be losing 10 from charging either way.

This then cancels out photon grenades and it's usefulness.  Kinda sad too, because they were really useful against me, as a DE player.

Of course, photon grenades are still useful against troops that don't have a shooting weapons, like warp beasts, some tyranids (i think), and perhaps orcs who suck at shooting anyway.

But, we can all see photon grenades are not going to be as useful as they used to be.  Hopefully GW will do a chapter approved to modify them a little.  Maybe changing it to those assaulting lose their two weapon bonus.. .or even, that if a unit shot at them, they only get half their attacks.

I'd hate to see a useful upgrade get shot down with the new rules.  Any opinions?

Offline Tobab816

  • Senior Member
  • ****
  • Posts: 1888
  • Chaos Warmaster, Promoter of Deathball!
Re:Photon Grenades and 4th edition assault.
« Reply #1 on: August 2, 2002, 07:38:37 AM »
Well actually Photon grenades ARE 4th edition wargear. So I doubt that we will see any changes.

The point with them are that the enemy is unable to make as many attacks in Close combat. Hence they arn't as likely to break the Tau unit in close combat.

Photon grenades forces the enemy to attack like YOU want him to do it. That is more shooting(which the tau can absorb with their 4+ armor) and less close combat attacks(which they tau are going to suffer very badly against).
Deathball, the new game of bloody basketball, 40k style!

+++Excerpt from Last Chaos/Space marine game, commentator: Inquisitor Khalheed "The Purgator" Qhor, Ex-Deathball player+++

Chaos vs Space Marine grudgematch today ended 23-19 when Brother Grazieel decimated the chaos team with a heavy bolter.

Afterwards the Chaos Coach Zhuriel the Damned stated "If we weren't ideologically in favor of cheating we'd complain about this""
+++End of transmission+++


Powered by EzPortal